Feature #656
closed[Calc] Add hard recalc in Menu/Tools/Cell contents
0%
Description
Following Ask, ML and Bugzilla, seems that there are a lot of people who don't know about hard recalc, finding it as an obscure option.
As it isn't in any place but in the help, only with a deep read you can know about it if nobody tells you.
Showing it next to Menu/Tools/Cell contents/Recalculate, at least makes it visible.
!C:\ApliPortables\Documents\Pictures\screenshot.11.png!
Files
Updated by Samuel Mehrbrodt about 10 years ago
- Status changed from New to In Progress
- Assignee set to Samuel Mehrbrodt
- % Done changed from 0 to 80
Submitted a patch for this, thanks for reporting: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/#/c/11305/
Do you have an idea for a better label than "Recalculate Hard"? To me it's not clear what's the difference between those two.
Updated by Miguel Ángel riosv about 10 years ago
Really thanks for a so quick implementation.
I think:
All cells recalculation
in contrast with Recalculate [F9], that only does the calculation for dependants of modified cells,
can express in an a more understable way for new and non expert user what it does.
Full recalculation
I think is also good and a bit more short.
Maybe Recalculate [F9] with those changes, also needs a more clear text like to differentate:
Modified cells recalculation
Updated by Samuel Mehrbrodt about 10 years ago
Thanks for the explanation.
How with this wording:
- Recalculate modified Cells (F9)
- Recalculate all Cells (Ctrl+Shift+F9)
Updated by Miguel Ángel riosv about 10 years ago
Fine for me.
But after review the help, maybe if we like being consistents in both places, and a bit more accurate.
Recalculate all changed formulas (F9)
Recalculate all formulas in the document (Shift+Ctrl+F9)
--------------------------------
Help text:
Recalculate
Recalculates all changed formulas. If AutoCalculate is enabled, the Recalculate command applies only to formulas like RAND or NOW.
To access this command...
Choose Tools - Cell Contents - Recalculate
F9
Press F9 to recalculate. Press Shift+Ctrl+F9 to recalculate all formulas in the document.
After the document has been recalculated, the display is refreshed. All charts are also refreshed.
The Add-In functions like RANDBETWEEN currently cannot respond to the Recalculate command or F9. Press Shift+Ctrl+F9 to recalculate all formulas, including the Add-In functions._
Updated by Samuel Mehrbrodt about 10 years ago
- Status changed from In Progress to Rejected
- % Done changed from 80 to 0
The patch has been rejected. Here's the comment from the reviewer:
I talked to Kohei and we both would like to avoid adding the Calculate Hard button.
The plan is to move away from having ever the need for a hard recalculation so this is counter-productive.
Updated by Miguel Ángel riosv about 10 years ago
Thanks for ask devs opinion.
Taken in account their comments, then sure it's better doesn't implement it for a brief time, it only could lead to confusion.
I only hope the solution will be implemented soon.