Project

General

Profile

Task #2362

Keywords in Bugzilla for ODF specification

Added by Regina Henschel 3 months ago. Updated 3 months ago.

Status:
New
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
Category:
-
Target version:
-
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:

0%

Estimated time:
Tags:
URL:

Description

Bugzilla has the keyword "filter:odf". That is similar to "filter:fodt" or "filter:pdf". It is meant for the Math component of LibreOffice. But because odf is also the abbreviation for "Opendocument Format" it produces confusion and wrong assignments. A keyword for issues connected with ODF specification does not exist yet.

Suggestion: rename "filter:odf" to "filter:odf(Math)" and introduce a new keyword "ODF".

History

#1 Updated by Beluga Beluga 3 months ago

Regina Henschel wrote:

Bugzilla has the keyword "filter:odf". That is similar to "filter:fodt" or "filter:pdf". It is meant for the Math component of LibreOffice. But because odf is also the abbreviation for "Opendocument Format" it produces confusion and wrong assignments. A keyword for issues connected with ODF specification does not exist yet.

Suggestion: rename "filter:odf" to "filter:odf(Math)" and introduce a new keyword "ODF".

In the descriptions: https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/describekeywords.cgi
.. it says: filter:odf Bugs that affect ODF FILEOPEN / FILESAVE.

So where does this "it is meant for Math" assumption come from?

#2 Updated by Beluga Beluga 3 months ago

Beluga Beluga wrote:

Regina Henschel wrote:

Bugzilla has the keyword "filter:odf". That is similar to "filter:fodt" or "filter:pdf". It is meant for the Math component of LibreOffice. But because odf is also the abbreviation for "Opendocument Format" it produces confusion and wrong assignments. A keyword for issues connected with ODF specification does not exist yet.

Suggestion: rename "filter:odf" to "filter:odf(Math)" and introduce a new keyword "ODF".

In the descriptions: https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/describekeywords.cgi
.. it says: filter:odf Bugs that affect ODF FILEOPEN / FILESAVE.

So where does this "it is meant for Math" assumption come from?

Right.. it should say open document formula..

#3 Updated by Regina Henschel 3 months ago

The problem is that the description "Bugs that affect ODF FILEOPEN / FILESAVE." is ambiguous.
If I look at the issues, where this keyword is currently used, then it seems, that people use it for problems with OpenDocument Format and not for Math. Which means, that there is no need for a keyword for Math. So it might be easier to make the description unambiguous and keep it for OpenDocument Format?

"Bugs in relation to OpenDocument Format specification"

#4 Updated by Xisco Fauli Tarazona 3 months ago

Yep, it seems no math documents use the keyword. I think changing the description would be enough here too.
Buovjaga, what do you think ?

#5 Updated by Beluga Beluga 3 months ago

Xisco Fauli Tarazona wrote:

Yep, it seems no math documents use the keyword. I think changing the description would be enough here too.
Buovjaga, what do you think ?

Ok I changed it to: Bugs that affect Open Document Format FILEOPEN / FILESAVE.

Also available in: Atom PDF